UK–devolved relations ‘too opaque’, Cambridge research warns

A postgraduate researcher at St John’s College says the structure governing cooperation across the UK lacks transparency and oversight

The way the UK Government works with Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland risks undermining democratic accountability, new research suggests.

Jack Liddall, a postgraduate student at St John’s College, University of Cambridge, has mapped more than 25 years of transparency measures covering how the UK Government works with Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland. He identified progress since the mid-2010s but says the system still falls short of meaningful scrutiny. The research is published in The British Journal of Politics and International Relations.

“Where decision-making is opaque and governments are not properly held accountable, UK publics can, in turn, lose trust in democratic institutions,” he explains.

“The years around 2016 and 2022 marked key moments for greater openness in intergovernmental relations. The opening up of intergovernmental processes to parliamentary examination - while far from complete - occurred chiefly as a response to changing political-constitutional contexts.”

Liddall argues that it was political shocks, namely the 2014 Scottish independence referendum and Brexit, that forced change. “The dramatic intergovernmental ‘high politics’ surrounding the Scottish independence referendum and Brexit proved decisive in securing greater government transparency, following other long-standing, often unsuccessful, campaigns for enhanced scrutiny.”

He says ministers’ motives were pragmatic rather than principled. “The rationales behind these government-introduced transparency measures have been less than altruistic. They have not primarily been in the name of good governance nor improved accountability.”

Instead, “the deepening of highly technical intergovernmental working necessitated by Brexit– alongside rising tensions between UK governments – drove executives to open up intergovernmental relations processes to parliamentary and public scrutiny.”

Liddall notes that around 80 per cent of the transparency measures were introduced post-Brexit, including promises to release brief public accounts of ministerial discussions and to provide regular updates to parliaments.

Scotland led with a 2016 written agreement to provide agendas, timely summaries and annual reports; Wales followed in 2019; UK-wide reforms arrived with a 2022 overhaul of intergovernmental machinery.

There are now pledges to publish agendas in advance, issue summaries after meetings and allow committees to question ministers on what was agreed, but Liddall argues that these practices are “applied unevenly and remain largely voluntary.” In many cases, his research found that meetings still take place informally, with patchy or minimal records and no automatic route for follow-up scrutiny in Westminster or the devolved legislatures.

He added: “The transparency measures which have been introduced are far from comprehensive, with the vast majority of intergovernmental relations still occurring informally and behind closed doors. A culture of transparency is far from embedded.”

Nor has the UK moved from disclosure to what he considers genuine oversight: “There has not yet been a major shift from a culture of intergovernmental relations transparency to a culture of scrutiny in which the UK’s ministers and civil servants are tangibly held to account for their contributions to intergovernmental decision-making.”

His bottom line is stark: “Intergovernmental relations transparency is both unenforceable and dependent on government cooperation.” Without stronger, shared standards for publishing agendas, minutes and outcomes - and clearer roles for committees across all four legislatures – he concludes that major UK-wide decisions will continue to be taken “out of sight”, with accountability blurred.

News
Research

Related articles

Image of Grenfall tower shortly after the fire
St John’s academic helps uncover decades of tower block safety warnings before Grenfell

A historian of modern Britain has helped create a major new digital archive that brings together 50 years of housing safety campaigns and gives today's tower block residents practical tools to fight for safer homes

News
Research
Studio Aalto, Villa Mairea, Noormarkku (1937-9), view from surrounding forest. Credit: Maija Kairamo. Finnish Heritage Agency
New book sheds light on the enduring legacy of Finland’s modernist pioneers

From sustainability to human-centred design, a St John’s College expert explores how the work of celebrated Studio Aalto anticipated some of the biggest challenges facing architects today

News
Research
A group of six men smile at the camera in front of a University of Cambridge building: the Ray Dolby Centre and 'Cavendish Laboratory
St John’s scientists at forefront of quantum revolution

Two St John’s researchers have secured funding to develop cutting-edge quantum technologies through a major partnership between the University of Cambridge and technology company IonQ

News
Research
A montage of Ben Weissenbach and his book
‘Beautifully written’ Alaska wilderness odyssey wins international literary prize

Book festival judges hail adventure travel memoir by St John’s postgraduate student as ‘a classic in the genre’

News